Saturday, April 12, 2008

Taking the Moral High Ground on Tibet

Sometimes, as an overseas ethnic Chinese with deep roots and an abiding cultural affinity to my ancestral land, I can't fathom the inscrutability of Chinese officials tasked with explaining China to the western world effectively. But I do have a clue which I will explain later here.

Take the Tibet riots. I can't think of any worse posture than to close off and simply clamp up when China has the moral "high ground" when the ruffians, rogues, and "political monks" who rampaged through Llasa, began killing innocent civilians and shopkeepers and looting their stores.

The ECONOMIST was the Only Western News Media who Accurately reported the Llhasa Tibet Riots

We saw those photos and videos which did not lie about what happened. They did not lie about the stoning and the lynching of innocent old people and women. We also read the Economist and its reporter, Mr. Miles' reporting of the violence by certain, and I must qualify this to say only a small number of indiginous Tibetans who were involved in these ugly riots.

What subsequently transpired with China's officialdom shutting off foreign press access to the scene of the riots underscored to me a high "cultural divide" between how Chinese officials look at this decision compared to Westerners and the Western press.

For Chinese officials, perhaps, the fear of "secret" spies and agent provocateurs, given the history of the CIA in Tibet and the exile government of the Dalai Lama in Dharamsala was clearly a significant factor in deciding against allowing foreign access. And in my own gut, I honestly suspect that there is more than meets the eye in terms of foreign governments in the West and perhaps their complicity in creating, financing, and staging these events.

I don't have the "smoking gun" yet. But I smell powder. Why ?

The footprints smack of "dead rats" and malodorous signs masked by French perfume from the West. Especially with the timing and massaging of the din of protests, recriminations, and denunciations being amplified in the Western press.

And especially timing the whole eruption close in time to the Taiwan elections. Was Ah Bian from Taipei and the Dalai Lama from Dharamsala talking to each other ?

I am a Chinese-American lawyer. I have been educated and conditioned in the American system of law, in theory and in practice. I have been in American courtrooms observing great trial lawyers perform their acts.

There is an often-promoted story among practitioners of courtroom law that validates the proposition that "if you see don't have the facts, just keep arguing the law."

What I am seeing in this Tibet riot narrative here in the Western world is that other than the Economist report by Mr. Miles, their field "eyeball" reporter, talking about the facts, and what he genuinely saw and thereafter reported, almost every other Western reporter and news media are talking not about the bare facts and stick with the bare facts. They are talking about the law.

Why ? Because these western news media don't have much facts. Thus, they are arguing the "law." The law of a free press. The right of access to cover the story.

I feel their righteousness. But you know, all said, after seeing how many "agent provocateurs" there are in the China bashing "Team Tibet-Shangri-La' narrative here in the West, including groups like "Reporters Without Borders" or "fake" reporters posing as news media and Western journalists, I can now also undertand the cautiousness and deep suspicion of Chinese authorities to allow foreign journalists access.

FAKE WESTERNERS POSING AS LEGITIMATE NEWS REPORTERS

Just look at what the "fake reporters" from "Reporters Without Borders" at the opening ceremonies in Greece. Or what they did in Paris. These are professional rabble-rousers and provocateurs out to undermine and stabilize China. And there is clearly a question about who is or are financing their antics and action.

The Western press has to understand that they too have to clean up their own acts.

There's just too much fakery, duplicity, and phoniness within their own news media organizations.

In fact, I know. Many Western officials have a tendency to talk from both sides of their mouths.

Our San Francisco mayor, for example. "On the one hand," he said, "I am for the Beijing Olympics and welcoming the Olympics torch to San Francisco."On the other hand, "I am against allowing the torch goes through the Himalayas and through Tibet."

Pardonez mois ? Did I hear you, the honorable Mr. Newsom ? Aren't you talking from both sides of your mouth ? And you are broadbrushing us Chinese as being "inscrutable"?

I know. I have been in the forefront of this battle to engage the Chinese peoples and the members of the Western world in a healthy, respectful dialogue beyond the din of the blame-game, the stridency of the accusations against China for "human rights abuses," and worse the ignorant China bashing and demonization.

Another good illustration of this is our own American Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi, supposedly representing my city, i.e. San Francisco.

In my view, Pelosi, who is the 3rd highest official in the U.S., after President Bush and Vice-President Cheney, is the almost archtypical "do-gooder" inspired and motivated by the "White Woman's Burden" to provide relief and rescue heroically the "poor masses of the Third World," i.e. especially young women and children, elderly and religious folks.

Her depth about Asia and China, in particular, is based on Hollywood movies like Pearl Buck's "The Good Earth," and the slew of movies which validate and reinforce the "White Man's Burden."

The "yellow hordes," in this type of Hollywood narrative, are just faceless, amorphous, and deaf-mute-dumb backdrops in Hollywood movies, acting as backdrops and extras. And Speaker Pelosi is the star a la "Mother Theresa", the white woman in a white dress coming to the rescue of the oppressed downtrodden. Damn you "Fu Manchu" villians, you devils in the high officials of the imperial court ! That appears to be her beef based on her "cultural dark glasses" Louis Vitton labeled, please.

Jane Fonda once did that too in Vietnam. And many war veterans from Vietnam never forgave her for this demagoguery. But Pelosi is from the same era, along the same mold, with good intentions but suffused with naivite, ignorance, and worse, obsessed with the oppression happening "over there." And to her, Chinese officials are just bad. Dead wrong. And dead evil.

When Pelosi went to India to stoke the flames after the Tibet riots, accompanied by right-wing known zealots on one side, and ultra-liberal "do-gooders" within the U.S. Congress, to demagogue her obsessed "China bashing" to do a "photo-op" with the Dalai Lama, she was really only "grandstanding" it without really thinking through that good intentions sometimes end with disastrous consequences.

As had been the case in America's quaqmire in Vietnam; and now in Afghanistan and Iraq.

And here we are, in the middle of stiffening positions. Chinese officials enraged by this Western bashing being orchestrated jointly from Europe and North America. And European officials such as Chancellor Angela Merkel, French President Nicholas Sarkozy, all suffused with "the White Man's Burden" to come to the rescue of the poor oppressed people of China, and especially in Tibet.

How naive. How myopic. And indeed, how ignorant.

The only Western leader, I suspect, at this time is Aussie Premier Kevin Rudd. This is one man who at least bothered to learn the Chinese language and Chinese history.

The rest reminds me of the William McKinleys of our times. President McKinley was the late American president who did not know where the Philippines was located in a map. And at the end of the Spanish-American war in 1898, when the U.S. ended up inheriting the colonies of Spain and ceded to the U.S. its colony in the Philippines, he knelt on the floor for divine guidance and prayed for God to give him some assistance to uplift the brown savages, the native Filipinos.

We are living in a world of globalization; yet notwithstanding all those doors opening, and what Mr. Friedman, the columnist of the New York Times kept dramatising, "The Earth is Flat. The Earth is Flat."

Peoples in the West, and especially their public officials, are still stuck in the mental "time-warp" of the past, and can't see whether or not they are coming or going in and about China. And worse, they still think the world is "round" after Mr. Friedman convincingly proved to us Asians that it is flat, and absolutely flat, metaphorically and actually. :-)

We can do better. And the Beijing Olympics games must go on, with or without Western leaders such as Merkel, Sarkozy, Brown, and Harper attending.

God forbid if Beijing officials lose their "photo ops" this summer with Sarkozy's new gorgeous wife, the First Lady of France. But with Chancellor Merkel ? Nah. Nah. Who would want to have their picture taken with her anyway ?

San Francisco Values - Perversity or Civil Liberties ?

You be the judge. Talk about San Francisco values and perversity.

After all the hectoring, abusive and assaultive behavior, and the well-schemed plan to ambush the Olympics torch relay runners at the 6 mile route of the relay in San Francisco's leg of the journey, the China bashers led by the "Team Tibet-Shangri-La-Dalai Lama" are again yelling victimization by the mayor and police chief of San Francisco.

This time, it is not China and its security forces accused of abusing their human rights. It is the San Francisco mayor and police chief :-):-)

Laugh Out Loud (LOL). The latest rallying cry is now: "San Francisco violated our rights of protest !"

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has weighed in on behalf of "Team Tibet Shangri-La-Dalai Lama" is reportedly poised to challenge the last minute change in the torch route.

The basis of this specious and ridiculous claim is that there is a city sunshine ordinance which requires our San Francisco mayor to fully disclose to the general public details of a public event in order to ensure the rights of dissenters and protesters to exercise their "First Amendment Rights" (sic) of free speech. And free speech means also free protest.

There are plans afoot by the ultra-liberal legal team of the American Civil Liberties Union to now pursue a full and robust hearing before the legislative body of San Francisco, i.e. the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, and the city's police commission.

And of course, Chris Daly, our San Francisco supervisor, also now known as "Chris Dalai," honorary son of the his Holliness, the Dalai Lama, is planning these hearings to continue to demagogue and amplify his righteous causes, except cleaning San Francisco's city's streets and minding the city's fiscal budget, at the precipice of a budgetary disaster of major proportion.

The menu of the day, or "menu de dia," (in Spanish), is "Why weren't the Anti-China protesters allowed the opportunity to produce their "publicity stunts" to attack and villify the world Olympics torch ?"

And more, "Why weren't the Western and American news media, with their cameras and slew of production crews, from CNN, NBC, Fox, CBC, Radio Canada, and a host of European film crews, who already set up their production scripts at the original relay route, with their pre-set "protest and riot lenses," be given the opportunity to film, amplify, produce, direct, and circulate this "Hollywood" narrative for the "Tibet-Shangrila" cause ?"

First Amendment rights ? Free speech rights ?

As a Chinese-American attorney based in San Francisco, talk about Western and American values ! Talk about our increasingly perverted application of the laws.

Anything for publicity, sensationalist Hollywood-style. Even to the point of amplifying a publicity stunt by three white "nutheads" who attempted to scale the Golden Gate Bridge to do a high profile publicity stunt, just to unfold a banner, in the name of protest.

For Pete's sake, can't these nuts just do it with high-tech graphics such as that Steven Spielberg, the well-known Hollywood film mogul, is so adept and creative in doing ?

By the way, no Western nor American news media cameras ever filmed the horrific traffic gridlock caused by these three "nuts." And I bet you that they don't even know where Tibet is in an Asian map. Or any more about Tibet other than what Richard Gere, the Hollywood actor, tells them.

That's America for you. Anything for publicity to dramatise any cause at all costs.

Welcome to San Francisco. Next to Hollywood, our city by the bay is known as a hub for crackpots, crackheads, and crackers. (The three "Cs"). What ever happened to the other "C" word, i.e. civility. Or how about "courtesy"?

And I am in the middle of this perversity.

And many of us who wanted to welcome the Olympics torch, including an old Chinese immigrant lady in her nineties, a former actress in Shanghai, can't even access Ground Zero of the welcoming ceremonies site because she was worried that she may end up being stampeded.

After what happened in Paris with a torch runner on a wheelchair near the Eiffel Tower being assaulted by a vicious "Team Tibet" protester, i.e. Paralympic athlete Jin Jing, I would not blame her.

Civil liberties ? American Civil Liberties ? Freedom to "mau mau" at will ? Even to the point of abusing, threatening to attack the torch runners, such as a paralympic on wheelchair in Paris ? and scaring the wits out of old ladies ?

And now threatening to sue under the much vaunted rights of the American Constitution.

Gimme a break. Perversity. Shame. and Down with Western warped values.

The Chinese peoples inside and outside China can do better. They must do better. And they don't need the Western and American news media to write the script, prepare the set, direct the narrative under their sensationaist "protest lenses."

We huarens overseas must call the West for it. Please, no more stunts. This is the real world we have. With all the conflicts and man's humanity against inhumanity all over the world, let's do the real thing - clean up our own house; look inside locally within our own society.

And please. Learn about China before you hector, scream, and demonize the Chinese peoples. Visit the country, by all means. And don't bring your baggage declaring "The White Man's Burden."

Calling All Huarens - Fight China Bashing and Demonization

To My friends from China and all Chinese around the world:

I know you are out there.

Many of you have been pained, anguished, and horrified by the travesty which has accompanied the highly politicized Olympics torch as it winds its way towards Beijing.

We can do better to tone down the rhetoric and push for the depolitization of the Olympics.

But at the same time, we can do so in a respectful and intelligent way. Yes, with passion and firm conviction, too. And we must tell the West that they can't interlope and interfere in China's sovereign affairs.

In short, "Butt Off, West." "Don't run ahead of the race."

I know the issue of Tibet and the Dalai Lama have gripped and taken all of us "goodwill" Huaren netizens in the internet, inside and outside China, in our Diasporic communities.

Many of us feel that we have been held hostage and this subject of Tibet has drowned out and superceded and pushed over everything else that matter in the spirit of these Olympics Games. We have seen the incivility and insults against the Chinese in London, Paris, and San Francisco.

I feel that unless we all act together, the forces of evil will triumph over the goodness that all of us have who support China's role in its rightful place before the world, hosting the Beijing Olympics games in particular.

I also understand why the Dalai Lama is viewed as a "splittist" and considered to be someone who talks from both sides of his mouth, on the one hand talking "autonomy" and then on the other hand, engineering and mobilizing his people from Dharamsala, to push the "I" word, i.e. Independence.

As a Chinese-American, I have seen how the internal forces at play within the Dalai Lama's own movement is viewed with mistrust.

And I know why. The old Chinese adage rings very true, " Watch what I say; but also observe what I do."

I have been in the vortex in San Francisco where the Dalai Lama's troops schemed, machinate, and produced their anti-China narrative, twisted Tibetan history, and pander to a naive, ignorant, and even stupid American public. His forces are very good at spin, especially directed towards the naive and ignorant public in the West, including its equally naive and ignorant public officials.

The Dalai Lama can't tell people he is for "non-violence" when we all see before our own eyes how his Tibetan supporters rioted in Llasa, and elsewhere inside Western China, including in Qinghai, Chengdu, etc. Those riots, further, were distorted in the West by Western news media through their "biased lenses" to portray that it was the Chinese government who abused the rioters, instead of the rioters abusing innocent, ordinary citizens.

Truth be told, the narrative has been twisted, distorted, and massaged by the Western press and amplified by Western governments. And we are calling the Western news media, on it. A free press? More like a reckless, irresponsible, China-bashing press.


The Dalai can't talk "non-violence' when his own supporters in the West, including in Europe and in America, assault, mau-mau, scream, hector, and uncivilly engage those of us in support of the Beijing Olympics 2008, in a relentless and vicious campaign of uncivil, rude, boorish, hooliganistic behavior.

He can't talk "non-violence" when the assaults by his "political monks" exceeded the boundaries of what religious men and women should and ought to do.

Buddhism is about peace. Yes. But we know and I have also seen violent buddhists, including buddhist monks in other parts of Asia, e.g. Vietnam, Burman, Korea, Japan, breach the call of "non-violence" and project violence and attack others. This is buddhism perverted. It is politics masked in religious verneer, with a theocratic hidden agenda.

Whenever politics get mixed up with religion, it is a "powder keg." The latest attempt to use the Beijing Olympics as a stage to soundblast, amplify, and push politically the cause of separatism inside China, is a manifestation of Western powers' neo-imperialist ambitions to destabilize and attack its western fringe, with hidden motives.

All of these, in my view, is designed to use the Olympics games, as a stage to push his "I" narrative, i.e. Independence, while mouthing the "A" word, "autonomy" while orchestrating and fomenting the divisve forces within China's polity.

You can't have it both ways, your Holliness. And to the West, we see through your hidden motives. And we are calling you on it.

I say this in all sincerity to the supporters of the Dalai Lama:

"I have seen your troops operate right here in San Francisco, in a boorish, uncivil, and downright rude behavior while the Dalai Lama professed innocence, and talk "non-violence."

"It is not "non-violent" when in Paris, a clearly disabled Chinese female youth in a wheelchair trying to carry the Olympics torch was assaulted by your "Team Tibet-Shangri La" supporter.
And I hear nothing from you when this mortified youth probably will have nightmares because of this assault."

Getting back to my call to all Huarens: let's work to steer the course of this catamaran sailing boat to ensure that rational voices of reason, mutual respect, and intelligence come into play in China-West relations.

Let's lower the din of yelling, screaming, and incivility.

And let's work truthfully to ensure that a respectful dialogue be started within China, without outside interloping, especially from the West, to make sure that China succeeds, without the forces of separatism and secession pushing to insult and worse harm our civilization for the long run.

Calling Huarens inside and outside of China: lets work to tell the West to butt out.

China's problems, as many as there are, are "Our problems" as Huarens. And the West has no right nor standing to interfere.

We can do better. Much better than the incivility, rudeness, and insults that are happening recently in the West.

Calling All Aussies - Don't Be London, Paris, or San Francisco

To my friends from Australia and New Zealand:

I know the Olympics torch relay will arrive in Canbrerra in a few days.

In your neck of the woods, I have heard from here, San Francisco, my hometown, stirrings of protest, and anecdotal reports of China bashing and demonization.

Most of these have been directed against the causes of human rights and grievances against Chinese officials and their government on a host of issues from Tibet, Xinjiang, China's environmental problems, extra-territorial issues of Darfur, Burma, and even the Paracel islands in South China.

Here in San Francisco, we even have people protesting that China is abusing animal rights, and slaughtering animals for food. Which society is not carnivorous, pray tell.

I eat hamburgers all the time, and they come from cows.

Lately, I have seen your premier, Kevin Rudd, chimed in, and lend his voices on the clamor for human rights inside China.

With all due respects to your bilingual premier, the only head of state in the West historically who is the closest to being knowleageable about Chinese culture and its rich civilization,, not ignorant as our very own American Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi, Mr. Kudd is best positioned to eloquently communicate in the Chinese language, without filters or translators.

Mr. Rudd must act to engage, not to lecture the Chinese. He must be a bridge builder, not a bridge destroyer.

That said, I plead for civility and call upon all Aussies to welcome the Olympics torch to Canbrerra in a few days. I know because of our experiences here in San Francisco with the demogoguery of our congresswoman, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who is from San Francisco.

We all may have grievances about politics and governance within our own countries where we reside. I too am not happy with many things I see and experience inside China as a Chinese-American straddled in both worlds.

I know. I have grievances too here in San Francisco, as an American. But I look at it as a glass "half-full" rather than a glass "half-empty" perspective. And those of us who are working very hard across cultures are unfortutely being drowned out by the forces of stridency, incivility, and China bashing.

Our government, the U.S., is mired deeply in the Iraq War to which we can't extricate ourselves as a nation, much less understand. And next, they are trying to pick a fight with Iran, an ancient Persian culture with a rich history.

Domestically, our financial systems, including Wall Street, is melting down. This past week alone, three of our airlines have shut down and declared bankruptcy in Hawai and America's heartland. Our airlines are besieged with bad and surly service, overloaded by the high costs of fuel, and strapped by eroding revenues. You Aussies must know when comparing airlines in Asia and in the United States.

Even our ordinary citizens, our "Johnny Six Packs" and "Soccer Jane Moms" are discovering that their pizzas and beer have gone up in prices. Many are losing their homes because they can't carry on with their mortgages. Some even are losing their cars because they can't absorb the financial overload and still pay for skyrocketing gasoline.

The high school my teenager child attends is saddled with budget problems such that we are facing teachers losing their jobs, downsized, and compelled to find employment other than teaching.

American health system is in shambles. Many of us can't afford the cost of basic health care, much less pay for prescription.

All said, we all face angst, anxiety, and concerns about the world and the suffering before us.

This is the worst of times I have seen in my short lifetime, especially in the West. And here in America.

Much of this anxiety and fear is that globalization has unleashed forces which are bringing us to unknown, unchartered waters. There is a lot of anger and frustration that CHINDIA, i.e. China and India, are overtaking the rest of the world with their dazzling success.

It is no different an angst in China as it is in the West, especially America, where I am today. And it is equally similar, I am sure in Australia. Inside China, many Chinese youths too are worried about gainful employment and how to cope with a slew of their own problems, like many of our Western youths in Europe, America, and Australia.

Those of us over here on the other side of the globe, have heard the din of protests emerging lately in Australia.

I feel that and I know the level of anxiety. I feel your pain. And I know much of these is being misdirected against China and its people, a country with at least fifty five (55) nationalities and ethnicities.

All these being said, as an American of Chinese descent, having experienced what happened here in San Francisco on April 9, 2008, in North America's oldest, most historic, most unique Chinese immigrant enclave, San Francisco Chinatown, we did the rest of the world, and especially the many decent people inside China some of the most bigoted, uncalled-for, and downright ignorant hectoring and insults. We did not do as well as we could to welcome the Olympics torch this week.

The Olympics games is a peoples' games. It is a world game to which Beijing for the first time in Chinese history of hosting. I am awed by the efforts being made by the peoples of China to make these games a success. These are the ordinary people I can relate and connect with.

Unfortunately, what we have seen and experienced in some western cities, especially in London, Paris, and San Francisco (my city) have not been all that honorable, civil, and dignified, as host cities welcoming the arrival of the torch as a peoples' event -- an event for world peace, harmony, and understanding.

We must do better. We must not repeat London, Paris, or San Francisco.

In each of these western cities, wracked by internal domestic problems of enormous proportion, we have seen the rising crescendo of incivility, rudeness, and hooliganism.

As much as we are all human beings, with differences in our political views, we must learn how to respect each other and not scream against each other. Bigotry must be stomped out.

As a Chinese-American who is straddled between two worlds, two cultures, and two sets of values, like your honorable and unique premier, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, I hope that Aussies can do better than the Brits, the French, and the Americans.

Where I am, in North America, we did better than the French in Europe. But I hope the Aussies can do better than the Americans. They must.

What happened in Paris was dishonorable. It is not I fondly remembered of French civility and decency. And Paris is one of my favorite cities. I learned Francophone culture, and I used to learn my French, Quebecois style, in Montreal.

But in the eyes of us dually-education Chinese-Americans, what many of us saw in our Western News Media, was uninvited incivility, boorishness, and hooliganism. I know because I was interviewed by German, Norwegian, French, and Canadian journalists here. And most are only gripped and filtered their news through the "protest lenses" of "Team Tibet-Shangri-La-Dalai Lama" and nothing else.

When I saw a crippled female Chinese-French torch bearer being assaulted by a Parisian protester, I cried for France. I cried for Europe. That's incivility from Europe.

And when I saw that our torch relay stop here in San Francisco was waylaid by our protesters here, and had to do an ad hoc shift to carry the torch by another route, notwithstanding that those of us here who are genuinely welcoming of the torch outnumber the protesters by a margin of 3 to 1, I was mortified at how these games have become politicized.

Aussies can do better. Let's honor the Olympics torch. It is our torch. Not any government's torch.

Let's not allow any protesters, regardless of their grievances against all the issues they are so passionate about, valid or invalid, real or imagined, wacky or legitimate, ambush and seize the stage, with incivility, rudeness, and boorishness.

And more, Let's not allow our supposedly free press in the western world, outside of China, use this occasion as a pretext to set up, stage, amplify and massage through their "protest lens" the China Bashing chorus that we have seen lately in London, Paris, and San Francisco.

As a Chinese-American, I call upon our Chinese Aussies to work to reach out in your neck of the woods to tamp down the negative and hostile passions, and really calmly and rationally engage the non-Chinese Aussies in a healthy dialogue. You are all Aussies, one nation; just as the Chinese inside, including its rainbow of nationalities including the Tibetans, are all Chinese, one nation.

I know many of our non-Chinese neighbors in the West are genuinely concerned and aggrieved by what they think or believe or may not have seen, but heard, through the biased prism of their own media, about China and its government. I ask them, "don't jump into conclusion until you visit China, and even more important, understand and read up on its complex history.

But be mindful, we are all people who transcends governments and government officials.

And the Olympics games is about people. Not governments, good or bad.

Learn not to be London, not to be Paris, and absolutely not be San Francisco.

I know Aussies, through your incredibly Chinese-fluent premier, can do better than us here.

Have a great torch relay. And give our best regards to our Aussie friends.

Sincerely,
Edward Liu
a Chinese American voice
San Francisco, California

Beijing Olympics - Not a Stage for China Bashing

Click on a commentary from San Francisco abut why the Beijing Olympics must not be used as a platform or stage for China Bashing and Demonization.

The commentary is co-uthored by Professor emeritus and former chair of the ethnic studies department of University of California Berkeley, and George Koo, a member of the Committee of 100, a Chinese-American civic organization which includes I.P Pei, the famous architect, and Yo-Yo Ma, famed cellist, as its luminaries-members.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2008/03/31/EDOIVSD61.DTL&type=printable

A Free But IRRESPONSIBLE Western Press

I am based in San Francisco.

This week, I was in the middle of "ground zero" right smack in the middle of the controversy over the Olympics torch relay in North America's only relay stop on its way to Beijing.

I must say that my respect for the Western media, as a whole, has been greatly diminished, if not destroyed.

My own personal interface with them, across the board, from Canada, Norway, Germany, and especially from the U.S., even my own supposed most liberal city, San Francisco, left me with a "bad taste" and seething anger. I know because I was interviewed first-hand by many of these supposed "journalists."

Just google me, "Edward Liu San Francisco" and you will find out more about me.

What I experienced was ignorance, cultural insensitivity, and worse, arrogance coupled by "cultural blinders" self-installed by many Westerners who harbor deep prejudices about China, its people, its culture, and civilization.

Worse, as the West, especially in Western Europe and the U.S. undergo the pains of globalization, with the fallout resulting in economic hardships, dislocations, and the erosion of the quality of life in the the West, many West have become jealous and downright hostile because of China's emergence as the "economic engine of the world."

It is very clear that India and China, two ancient civilizations have drawn attention and caused a lot of angst, anxiety, and anger from the West, especially as their societies improve, instead of regress, as is happening in many European and American cities, including my city, San Francisco.

As part of over 160 Chinese community organizations in our city mobilized to support the Beijing Olympics games , I and many other Chinese-Americans wanted to welcome the torch relay and simply experience the spirit of "One World, One Harmony" like many others who believe in this theme.

Instead, the San Francisco torch relay was sidetracked and exploited by dark forces bent on kidnapping this relay to their own mischievous political causes and policitising the whole thing.

And behind it, the Western news media played their roles as amplifier, co-producer, co-director, co-cameramen, co-actors, co-actresses in this pre-set script to push the "Team Tibet-Shangri-La-Dalai Lama" anti-China narrative and movie.

Worst, what I saw and experienced, was that many Western news media reporters were using the relay to make the news and filter the news through their "protest lenses" to dramatise their biases, prejudices, and a pre-set script to push for the "Team Tibet Shangri-La Dalai Lama" narrative. In so doing, they, in a sinister and highly unprofessional way, drowned out everything else except the dramatization and amplication of the protests.

Those of us who showed up to demonstrate our welcome and support of the Beijing Olympics Games were drowned out, ignored, and disrespectfully portrayed as "agents of the Chinese government," "shills for China," and against human rights causes. This is not just China Bashing but Chinese Demonization.

Our side of the counter-narrative, pro-Beijing Olympics, was not only distorted, ignored, and blockaded by the Western news media.

This included our local newspaper, the San Francisco Chronicle. This in America's most historic, most unique Chinese enclave, the way station for the historic influx and immigration of Chinese settlers in America.

In the din of this reckless and irresponsible reporting, one local columnist, C.W. Nevius, even had the audacity of accusing those of us who mobilized to welcome the torch relay as attempting "to take over San Francisco." Many of his fellow colleagues even implied that we were "bused" by the local Chinese consulate to create a public relations spectacle.

At ground zero, I said this to the Western news reporters who refused to cover our side of the story. Worse, many distorted the picture and filtered the news coverage, according to their own biases and prejudices.

"What good is a free press when you are an irresponsible press ?"

"What good is free speech when you don't exercise it civilly and simply scream, insult, and yell at others who may not share the same views as yours ?"

Many in the West have accused China of disallowing access to cover the Tibet riots which erupted in Lhasa, Tibet; their news media have accused China of not allowing freedom of the press.

I say to them," You have access here in San Francisco. Why not cover us who are supportive of Beijing's hosting of the Olympics games?" "Why do you not see us, listen to us and simply focuse on those who oppose the Beijing Olympics games ?"

"You have access here; yet you refuse to cover us and our side of the welcoming narrative; and instead, you become an amplifier for "Team Tibet-Shangri-La-Dalai Lama" ?

"Worse, you become complicit in hate-mongering and China-bashing."

"What good is access when you look but don't see ? Hear but not listen? "

What good is it if you don't exercise your press freedom responsibly ?

Clearly, accuracy, fairness, and balance were trampled in San Francisco on April 9, 2008 here in San Francisco.

On the San Francisco leg of the Beijing Olympics relay, ignorance, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness won. Civility and Mutual Respect lost out.

Let's work to improve upon our game as ethnic Chinese overseas who firmly believe in our "Third Space" vision and agenda.

I am outraged by the China Bashing and Chinaman lynching that day.

And shame on the English language and European news media at ground zero of the San Francisco leg of the Beijing Olympics 2008 torch relay.

Clearly, they are using the Bejing Olympics games as a platform to badmouth China and its government. And in this din, the peoples of China were insulted, disrespected, and sacrificed in their "menu of the day" to cover China through their "protest lenses."

And in so doing, they have recklessly and irresponsibly ignored that it is the Chinese peoples games and it is those who may have some genuine grievances against some of their government policies, but nonetheless that these games and their stories must be covered and be reported responsibly.

We need to call the Western news media on this. And in particular, I want to call upon the world to call upon your news media organizations in the area where you reside, as I have with our local newspaper, the San Francisco Chronicle, for their irresponsible reporting.

And we who have this "Third Space" eye must not let it go without calling it as we see it.

Bias. Prejudices. And worse. Racism against the Chinese people must not be tolerated.

We are no longer the "sick men" of Asia. We have our rights to be at the global table.

BEIJING OLYMPICS 2008 - MAKE IT A SUCCESS

The eyes of the world is focused on China and the Beijing Olympics Games this summer.

Lately, as ordinary Chinese inside and outside China watch in horror how these games have been used as a platform for the political machinations of anti-China forces in the West, stoking the fires of hate, demonization, and insults, I was saddened by it all.

China Bashing is again on the rise.

And with it Chinese peoples all over the world must rise up and fight against these forces of evil bent on distorting our narrative and our side of the story.

Many ordinary Chinese inside China, who have watched the bashing in the Western press especially from Europe, North America, Australasia believe that despite many problems they have in China, their country has not been treated fairly.

We agree. And we support their angst, anger, and understand their frustration.

Remember over 10 years ago when many of us mobilized in protest against ethnic Chinese persecution in Indonesia and Huaren.org was launched ? I was part of that movement.

Then, I had maintained that we ethnic Chinese overseas must push for a "Third Space." To this day, it is still my firm conviction, my dream and my vision.

The word, "Huaren," became a synonym for "ethnic Chinese overseas."

We ethnic Chinese overseas, aka Huarens, have to have a voice to report our narrative; to push for our rightful place in the sun.

We have to underscore that as a people straddled between our homeland and our new society whereever we have resettled, we have to be treated as human beings.

We have to be treated equally by our adopted countries and to live in dignity in our adopted land.

We have a right to the fundamental rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness in our own unique way, just as any other dignified peoples around the world.

That said, our fates as Huarens, no matter what, are always affected and impacted upon by the good things as well as the evil things in our midst.

Worse, during tensions between China, our roots, and the outside world, we get bashed by the forces of bigotry, intolerance, and anti-China hysteria.

Inspite of globalization, the fact is CHINA-WEST relations, especially CHINA-U.S. relations remain one which is characterized as misguided, misinformed, and misunderstood "mood swings."

Like a pendulum, it swings between good mood and bad mood.
And anytime that these mood swings change from one of euphoria, happiness to demonization and China bashing, our Huaren fate became intertwined and affected.
We need to do better as a people with dual backgrounds to keep the relationship on an even-keel.

Like a Catamaran sail boat, we must push for balance.
We can act as a bridge between CHINA and the WEST. We can push for our voices collectively, passionately, and uniquely in all of our unique backgrounds.

I say this because many of us are knowleageable and have experienced cross-culturally. We speak and write in many languages.

And because of our experiences with dual backgrounds, we all have a "third eye."
Thus, my vision to work for " a Third Space."Thanks to Bevin Chu, our fellow Huaren based in Taiwan, I will be reactivating my blog, " http://spatiumtrientis.blogspot.com/

Bevin has graciously linkd my blog with his blog. http://thechinadesk.blogspot.com/
We share the same passion. We may not agree on all things and everything. But we have great respect with each other, as with many of you from Huaren.org
And I hope we can all connect and fight for our rightful place in the sun, in our own way, as well as collectively, in our own space.

My blog, " http://spatiumtrientis.blogspot.com/ is based on the latin translation of "Third Space."

Let's mobilize again. And this time, let's do better and improve.
We have learned from the past. And we will keep in mind that all Huarens are smart, not dumb or deaf.

Cheers,Edward Liu